Co-written and first recorded by Margaret Lewis (1965, released 1995).
Hit versions by Johnny Adams (R&B #8/C&W #28 1969), Ray Pillow (C&W #38 1969), Narvel Felts (US #67/C&W #2 1975).
From the wiki: “‘Reconsider Me’ is a Country/Soul ballad written by Margaret Lewis and Mira Smith, and first recorded by Lewis in 1965 but shelved until its 1990s release on the Ace Records compilation album Shreveport Stomp – Ram Records, Vol. 1. Johnny Adams’s 1969 version was his biggest hit, peaking at #8 on the R&B chart and #28 on the Billboard Country singles chart. In the same year Ray Pillow’s country version hit #38 on the country charts. The highest charting version is by American country music artist Narvel Felts, peaking at #2 on the Billboard Country singles chart.”